“On the average, five times as many people read the headline as read the body copy. When you have written your headline, you have spent eighty cents out of your dollar.”
— David Ogilvy

Think about the last time you clicked an ad or a link.

How often have you landed on the page and immediately wondered: am I in the right place?

Maybe you searched for “emergency plumber” and the headline you’re greeted with is something like:

Family-run business

That’s a problem.

Whenever you run an ad, publish content, or share a link, you’re making a promise.
Your headline is where that promise either gets paid off — or broken.

It’s the most important part of your webpage's hero section (everything visible before scrolling).
Its job is simple:

1. Confirm the visitor they’re in the right place
2. Give them a reason to keep scrolling

Before we look at what works, let’s be clear about what doesn’t.

Headlines That Don’t Work

Avoid these:

“Welcome to _____”
“[Business name here]”
“We do XYZ”
“Trusted XYZ provider since 2008”
“Leading XYZ in Nottingham”
“30 years’ experience in XYZ”
“Award-winning XYZ”
“XYZ in Southampton”

None of these tell me why I should care.

They don’t explain why you’re different, better, or worth choosing over any other roofer, accountant, solicitor, or consultant nearby.

Don’t just talk about who you are and what you do.
And don’t say you’re “trusted” or “reputable”.

Anyone can say that. Most do.

Real trust is inferred, not announced.

The Real Job of a Headline: Pay Off the Promise

Your headline isn’t there to describe your business.

It’s there to answer the unspoken question your visitor has when they land:

“Why should I give a shit?”

People don’t click because they want a service.
They click because they want an outcome.

Not “I need a bookkeeper” — but what that bookkeeper gives them.

Less stress.
More time.
Clarity.
Control.
Peace of mind.

If you want stronger headlines, you need to start there.

Turn Problems Into Outcomes

Here’s a simple exercise.

First, write down the problems your customers actually complain about — in their words.

Example: a bookkeeper.

Problems

• I’m spending all my evenings doing the books
• I don’t know how much tax I owe
• I don’t trust my numbers
• My accounts are a mess
• I’m weeks behind because we’re so busy

Now write the outcome they want after working with you.

Outcomes

• I get my evenings back
• I know exactly what I owe — no surprises
• I feel confident the numbers are right
• Everything’s organised and easy to see
• I can focus on running the business

You’re no longer selling bookkeeping.
You’re selling time, confidence, control, and relief.

People buy emotionally first. Logic comes later.

No one buys a plane ticket — they buy the holiday.

Turning Outcomes Into Headlines

Let’s start with a typical headline:

“Trusted bookkeepers in Shoreditch since 1992”

Shite. We can do much better.

Take one problem + outcome pair:

I’m spending all my evenings doing the books
I’ll get my evenings back

That becomes:

“Your evenings shouldn’t be spent on bookkeeping”
“Get your weekends back”
“Free up your nights with done-for-you bookkeeping”

Take another:

I’m behind on my books
I can focus on real work again

Becomes:

“Stop worrying about being behind on the books”
“Finally feel caught up with your accounts”
“Focus on your business — we’ll handle the books”

These are already stronger. But we can push further.

From Telling to Proving

A good headline says why you should care.
A great headline proves it.

This is where numbers matter — if they’re real.

Think about what you actually help customers achieve. You may already track this.

‍

Examples:

Save 10 hours per week
Cut admin time by 30%
Save £1,200 per year
Results in 7–10 days
500 jobs completed this year
Spend less than 1 hour a week on X
Zero missed deadlines
120+ businesses helped
Most clients see results within 30 days

‍

Now layer that proof into the headline:

“Save 12 hours a week — let us handle your books”
“Spend less than 30 minutes a month on your finances”
“Catch up on your accounts within 7 days”
“Behind on your books? Fixed by next week”
“Cut admin time by up to 50% with done-for-you bookkeeping”

‍

That’s the shift:
from claims to evidence.

Just don’t fudge the numbers. Ever.

What to Do Next

Write 5–10 headline options using this approach.

Pick one.
Run it for 1–2 weeks.
Measure what happens.

If it performs better — great.
If not, swap it for the next one.

Rinse and repeat until you land on the strongest performer.

If you’ve made it this far, congratulations — this is the single most impactful change you can make to a landing page without touching design, traffic, or ads.

‍

If you'd rather someone else do this for you, drop us a line and we'd be happy to help!